GLOBAL SUBSIDIES INITIATIVE
Kinds of subsidies, who uses them and how big they are
Globally, subsidies to fossil fuels may be on the order of US$ 600 billion per year, of which the GSI estimates about US$ 100 billion is provided to producers. Nobody knows the real number, however, because there is no international framework for regularly monitoring fossil-fuel subsidies.
Clearly a more accurate picture is needed. Subsidies to consumers that lower end-user prices are relatively easy to estimate using the ‘price-gap' approach but producer subsidies come in many forms. These include tax breaks, low-interest loans, discounted royalties or access rights, and insurance guarantees. Support from such sources is rarely explicit in government budgets.
The GSI aims to improve subsidy estimates and is forging a new global understanding about fossil-fuel subsidies by:
- Undertaking a detailed survey of fossil-fuel subsidies and their characteristics across four significant and diverse countries: China, Germany, Indonesia and the United States.
- Providing new data and analysis on producer subsidies through detailed country studies, starting with the oil sectors in Indonesia and Canada.
- Developing an online calculator for estimating consumer subsidies.
- Developing better guidance on methodologies used for estimating fossil-fuel subsidies, including a paper analysing the pros and cons of the price-gap approach, and a technical manual that explains how to use a range of subsidy estimation methodologies.
-
Subsidies to Liquid Transport Fuels: A comparative review of estimates
Download:
Subsidies to Liquid Transport Fuels: A comparative review of estimates (PDF - 913 KB) -
Subsidies and External Costs in Electric Power Generation: A comparative review of estimates
-
Tax and royalty-related subsidies to oil extraction from high-cost fields: A study of Brazil, Canada, Mexico, the UK and the US
-
Fossil Fuels – At What Cost? Government support for upstream oil activities in three Canadian provinces
Download:
- Fossil Fuels – At What Cost? Government support for upstream oil activities in three Canadian provinces: Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Newfoundland and Labrador (PDF - 4.0 MB)
- Key Findings (PDF - 404KB) -
Fossil Fuels – At What Cost? Government support for upstream oil and gas activities in Norway
-
Fossil Fuels – At What Cost? Government support for upstream oil and gas activities in Indonesia
Download:
- Fossil Fuels – At What Cost? Government support for upstream oil and gas activities in Indonesia (PDF - 2.33 MB)
- Executive Summary (Indonesian) (PDF - 477 KB) -
Mapping the Characteristics of Producer Subsidies: A review of pilot country studies
Download:
Mapping the Characteristics of Producer Subsidies: A review of pilot country studies (2.88 MB)The ability to undertake meaningful subsidy reform, either nationally or multilaterally, is hampered by a lack of knowledge about the extent of support to the sector and where information on this support might be held. This paper helps increase the body of knowledge about the data sources that hold information on subsidies to fossil-fuel producers, by reviewing available data in a series of countries, diverse in terms of their level of data transparency, governance systems, energy markets and stages of economic development.
-
Measuring subsidies using the price-gap approach
Download:
Measuring Price Subsidies Using the Price-Gap Approach: What does it leave out? (498KB)The price-gap approach is one of the most commonly employed methodologies for estimating fossil-fuel subsidies: an examination of differences between the observed price for a good or service in the economy against what that price would be without government intervention. This report explains how the price-gap method works, reviews its benefits and limitations, and explores potential systematic bias in estimates, drawing conclusions and implications for their interpretation.
-
Subsidy Estimation: A survey of current practice
Download:
Subsidy Estimation: A survey of current practice (4.97 MB)This document is a technical manual addressed primarily to those individuals who are interested in preparing estimates of subsidies to particular products or sectors – people who engage in what might be called "subsidy accounting." It draws together the different valuation methods that are used and have been published, mainly by intergovernmental organizations and governments. While for most estimation methods the manual quotes multiple sources, often the approaches do not actually differ fundamentally, and users may simply want to refer to the one that makes most sense to them. In cases where they do differ markedly, users should choose whichever method best serves their purposes and can be implemented with the available data.
-
Scoping the feasibility of fossil-fuel subsidy estimation
Download:
Feasibility Study for "Revealing the Scale of Subsidies to Fossil Fuels"In 2007, a feasibility study for the estimation of fossil-fuel subsidies was conducted by the EPFL (ETH Lausanne) with inputs from the Global Subsidies Initiative (GSI) and Paul Scherrer Institut (PSI). The study reviews the literature on fossil-fuel subsidy estimation, provides a brief overview of major producing and consuming nations, outlines the available international data and discusses possible strategies for the improving the existing body of knowledge, including national-level data collection, accounting for externalities and developing a research program for further work in this area.